,

Why Do Managers Struggle With Reviews and Feedback?

Posted by

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready…


How It Happens

Let’s explain why feedback feels difficult, what blocks managers, and how simple structural changes can make a huge difference.

When expectations are unclear, feedback feels personal.

Managers worry:

  • “Am I judging too harshly?”
  • “Is this just my opinion?”
  • “What if they disagree?”

Without clear outputs, feedback turns into debate.

Managers avoid debates.

Many managers were promoted because they were good at the job.

Not because they were trained to:

  • Give feedback
  • Handle tension
  • Set expectations

They are asked to lead people using instincts, not tools.

That makes reviews stressful.


In many teams:

  • Feedback only happens when something is wrong
  • Reviews pile up issues over months
  • Conversations feel heavy

This turns reviews into emotional events instead of routine check-ins.

Managers delay what feels painful.

Common problems include:

  • Vague review forms
  • Too many criteria
  • No clear rating meaning

Managers are left to “figure it out.”

When the system is unclear, avoidance becomes the safest option.

Managers worry about:

  • Damaging relationships
  • Lowering morale
  • Causing exits

So they soften messages or stay silent.

Short-term peace replaces long-term clarity.


Why This Hurts Performance

Performance systems do not fail because SMEs lack discipline. They fail because the systems ignore reality.

When feedback is avoided:

  • Issues grow quietly
  • High performers feel unseen
  • Poor performance lingers

Teams drift instead of improving

What Makes Feedback Easier for Managers

What Makes Feedback Easier for Managers

Feedback becomes easier when:

  • Role outputs are clear
  • Success is defined early
  • Check-ins are regular and short
  • Feedback is about work, not personality

Clarity removes emotion from the process.



Shift Reviews From Events to Habits

Shift Reviews From Events to Habits

Strong teams do not rely on big review moments.

They:

  • Talk about output often
  • Correct early
  • Adjust fast

This makes formal reviews simple summaries—not confrontations.


Final Thought About Performance Reviews

Managers do not avoid feedback because they don’t care.

They avoid it because the system makes it risky.

Give managers clarity, and feedback stops feeling hard—it starts feeling normal.

Word From Our
Performance Advisor


Most managers avoid reviews not because they don’t care—but because the system puts them in a hard spot.

Male - Fractional HR Partner
Martin O. Ojwang Lead Partner – Performance Management

Chief Brand Builder at   View Full Profile

Victor Isyamba is the Lead Partner in charge of HR Systems & Processes. He designs and deploys simple HR workflows and business models that reduce errors, confusion, and leadership frustration.

Performance Advisor at   View Full Profile

Martin is a results-driven Fractional Performance Management Consultant who helps African teams move from activity to outcomes. Specializing in OKRs, KPIs, and performance review systems, Martin ensures managers can confidently run fair, motivating performance conversations.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Index